The Atlantic City Sub Shop’s Cheesesteak Sub – A Consistently Excellent Choice for 2025

Cheesesteaks have long been a favorite American sub, but finding the perfect one can be a challenge, especially in a region like the Atlantic City area, known for its variety of sub shops. One sub, however, has earned a spot at the top of the list for its consistency and deliciousness.

Located on the Northfield – Egg Harbor Township border, the “Atlantic City Sub Shop” has made a name for itself as home to one of the best cheesesteak subs in the region. Although the shop’s name might suggest it’s in the heart of Atlantic City, it is in fact just a short drive away, in a prime location serving up a flavor-packed cheesesteak that locals and visitors can’t get enough of.

A Consistent Favorite

This past Saturday, January 10, 2025, I had the chance to revisit the Atlantic City Sub Shop and try their cheesesteak sub once again. After years of enjoying their sandwiches, I can confidently say that their version is one of the best around, consistently delivering in terms of flavor, freshness, and quality.

It’s easy to see why this cheesesteak stands out in a region with several popular competitors, such as The White House Sub Shop, Pete’s Subs, Dinos Sub Shop, Tony Baloney’s, and Sack ‘O Subs. These spots each offer their take on the iconic sub, but the Atlantic City Sub Shop continues to set the bar high.

The Perfect Ingredients

The Atlantic City Sub Shop’s cheesesteak sub isn’t just any sandwich. It’s a carefully crafted meal that starts with the freshest ingredients.

• Steak: Generous portions of steak are cooked to perfection, tender and flavorful.
• Provolone Cheese: The rich, creamy provolone adds the perfect touch to balance the savory steak.
• Tomato: Fresh tomato slices bring a burst of flavor that complements the rest of the ingredients.
• Atlantic City Sub Roll: The bread is the true star of the show. Known for its fresh, soft texture, it’s an essential part of what makes this cheesesteak sub stand out. A sub without the right bread simply isn’t a sub.

To elevate the experience, I opted to add a little hot pepper for a spicy kick, though the sub is fantastic even without it. The combination of these ingredients, paired with light oil, makes for a sandwich that’s a cut above the rest. The sub roll is so important that without it, the sandwich wouldn’t be the same. The Atlantic City sub bread needs to be fresh; anything stale would ruin the experience, so it’s no surprise that the shop ensures its bread is always fresh.

The Importance of Freshness

The importance of fresh bread cannot be overstated. In the world of sub sandwiches, a stale roll can ruin an otherwise delicious sub. For those who’ve had the pleasure of enjoying a fresh Atlantic City sub roll, you know it’s what sets this sub apart from the others. A sub without it would simply be a sandwich, and no one wants that. If you happen to come across stale bread, it’s better suited for bread pudding than for a cheesesteak sub.

When the bread is as fresh as it is at the Atlantic City Sub Shop, you’re guaranteed an exceptional sandwich every time.

Why This Cheesesteak Stands Out

What truly sets this cheesesteak apart is its balance of ingredients and the commitment to freshness. While many shops serve up delicious cheesesteaks, the Atlantic City Sub Shop excels by consistently offering the right combination of tender steak, flavorful provolone cheese, fresh tomato, and the freshest bread in the area.

It’s not just about the ingredients; it’s about the experience. Every bite of this cheesesteak is a reminder of why this sub has earned a loyal following over the years. It’s satisfying without being overly heavy, flavorful without being too greasy, and always fresh.

Other Great Food Options in the Area

While the Atlantic City Sub Shop’s cheesesteak sub is certainly a standout, the Atlantic City area is known for many other excellent dining options. Whether you’re in the mood for Italian, seafood, or a hearty steak, the region has something for everyone.

For example, Capriccio Italian Restaurant at Resorts Casino is known for its delicious Italian dishes, including their famous Vitello Romero. Vic & Anthony’s Steakhouse offers some of the best steaks in town, including a 22-ounce Prime Bone-In Ribeye. If seafood is more your style, Steve & Cookies by The Bay in Margate is an excellent choice for a seafood pan roast.

Other local favorites include Docks Oyster House, Smithville Inn, and II Mulino New York at the Hard Rock Casino, each offering exceptional meals in their respective categories.

A Legacy of Great Food

As for the Atlantic City Sub Shop, it has proven time and again that it deserves a spot among the best in the area. From the moment you take your first bite to the last, you’ll appreciate the attention to detail and the dedication to providing a high-quality sub. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, the Atlantic City Sub Shop’s cheesesteak is an experience you won’t want to miss.

So, if you’re ever in the Atlantic City area, make sure to stop by the Atlantic City Sub Shop. It’s a simple, satisfying, and unforgettable cheesesteak experience that’s worth every bite.

Disclaimer – Our editorial team has thoroughly fact-checked this article to ensure its accuracy and eliminate any potential misinformation. We are dedicated to upholding the highest standards of integrity in our content.

About The Author