Why President Trump’s Social Security Promise Is Set to Fail and Why That’s the Right Move

Social Security is one of the most important financial safety nets for millions of Americans, providing critical income to retirees, survivors of deceased workers, and people with disabilities. For more than 90 years, it has been an integral part of the American social contract, lifting millions out of poverty and offering a reliable income for those in their later years. However, as it stands today, the program is facing an increasingly dire financial outlook. According to the latest Trustees Report, the Social Security system is heading toward a shortfall that could threaten its ability to continue making full payments to beneficiaries in the future.

In this context, President Donald Trump’s recent promise to eliminate the taxation of Social Security benefits has sparked both support and concern. While the proposal has been well-received by many, particularly retirees who feel burdened by taxes on their benefits, it is ultimately a promise that could deepen the program’s financial problems. In fact, breaking this promise may be necessary to preserve the long-term viability of Social Security, and it could be the right decision for the program and its beneficiaries.

The Financial Health of Social Security

Before diving into the implications of Trump’s plan, it’s important to understand the current state of Social Security’s finances. The program is primarily funded through payroll taxes, with workers and their employers contributing 6.2% of earned income to the trust funds. In recent years, however, Social Security’s financial health has been deteriorating due to several factors, including demographic shifts, rising income inequality, and the financial challenges posed by the aging U.S. population.

The Social Security Board of Trustees has consistently reported a growing shortfall in the program’s finances. In 2024, the projected long-term funding obligation shortfall reached an alarming $23.2 trillion. This figure represents the difference between the expected income from payroll taxes, interest on reserves, and the expected outflows for benefits and administrative costs from 2024 to 2098. Although Social Security is not at risk of disappearing or going bankrupt, the current trajectory is unsustainable. If nothing is done to address this shortfall, significant benefit cuts may be required to keep the system afloat.

The Old-Age and Survivors Insurance Trust Fund (OASI), which is responsible for paying monthly benefits to retirees and survivors of deceased workers, is expected to run out of reserves by 2033. If this happens, benefits could be cut by up to 21% to ensure the system can continue paying beneficiaries. Such cuts would have a devastating impact on the millions of Americans who rely on Social Security as a primary source of income.

Trump’s Promise to Eliminate Taxes on Social Security Benefits

In July 2024, President Trump made a promise on his social media platform, Truth Social, stating, “Seniors should not pay tax on Social Security.” This declaration was well-received by many, particularly retirees who have long resented the fact that their Social Security benefits are subject to federal taxation.

The idea of ending the taxation of Social Security benefits is not new. In 1983, during another period of financial strain for the program, Congress passed the Social Security Amendments, which introduced the taxation of benefits for the first time. At that time, it was expected that only a small percentage of seniors would be affected. However, due to inflation and rising income levels over the years, more and more retirees now find themselves subject to taxes on their benefits. Currently, up to 50% of Social Security benefits can be taxed if provisional income (adjusted gross income plus tax-free interest and half of benefits) exceeds certain thresholds. For higher earners, up to 85% of benefits are taxable.

Trump’s proposal to eliminate these taxes would result in higher monthly payouts for many retirees. However, this proposal overlooks the financial challenges facing the program. While it might provide some short-term relief to seniors, it would exacerbate the program’s long-term funding shortfall.

The Consequences of Eliminating Taxes on Social Security Benefits

Social Security generates income in three primary ways:

1. Payroll Taxes: The 6.2% payroll tax on earned income is the largest source of revenue for Social Security, accounting for the majority of its income.
2. Interest on Reserves: The program also earns interest on its asset reserves, which are invested in special-issue government bonds.
3. Taxation of Benefits: The taxation of Social Security benefits, which has become an increasingly important income source over time, is the third major source of revenue for the program.

In 2023, the payroll tax accounted for 91.3% of the $1.351 trillion in income collected for the combined OASI and Disability Insurance trust funds. However, the taxation of benefits has become a growing source of income for the program, contributing more than $30 billion in 2023. If Trump’s promise were kept and the tax on Social Security benefits were eliminated, an estimated $943.9 billion in revenue would be lost over the next decade (2024 to 2033). This loss would significantly worsen the program’s already precarious financial situation.

Without this critical source of income, the OASI’s reserves would be depleted even more quickly, accelerating the date at which benefit cuts would be required. If this tax were removed, the estimated depletion date for the OASI’s reserves could occur even sooner than the projected 2033 date, making the program’s long-term solvency much more uncertain.

The Political Realities of Trump’s Social Security Plan

One of the key challenges in implementing Trump’s promise to eliminate the taxation of Social Security benefits is the political reality of getting it done. In order to make such a significant change to the Social Security Act, Trump would need bipartisan support in Congress, including 60 votes in the Senate. This is a formidable challenge, as the last time either political party held a supermajority of votes in the Senate was in 1979.

It is unclear whether Trump’s plan would have enough support from both parties to pass in Congress. Even within the Republican Party, which generally favors tax cuts, there is resistance to proposals that could worsen the financial health of Social Security. Additionally, many Democrats are unlikely to support a plan that would increase the deficit and jeopardize the program’s long-term stability. Given the political gridlock in Washington, it seems unlikely that Trump will be able to fulfill this promise, and it may be necessary for him to break it.

Why Breaking the Promise Is the Right Decision

While breaking this promise would be politically unpopular, it may ultimately be the right decision for the future of Social Security. The reality is that the program’s finances are unsustainable without significant changes, and eliminating the tax on Social Security benefits would make the problem even worse.

Rather than focusing on short-term political gains, policymakers must prioritize the long-term health of Social Security. This will require difficult decisions, including increasing the payroll tax, adjusting the full retirement age, and finding ways to generate more revenue for the program. It may also involve cutting benefits for wealthier retirees who do not rely as heavily on Social Security for their income. These changes will be difficult to implement and will likely face resistance from various interest groups, but they are necessary to ensure that Social Security remains solvent and continues to serve future generations of retirees.

In the end, President Trump may have no choice but to break his promise to eliminate the taxation of Social Security benefits. While this will disappoint many retirees who were hoping for larger payouts, it could be the best option for preserving the program’s long-term solvency. By making difficult decisions now, we can ensure that Social Security continues to provide critical support to seniors and future generations of Americans who depend on it.

Conclusion

Social Security is a vital program that provides financial security to millions of Americans, particularly retirees. However, the program is facing significant financial challenges that must be addressed in order to ensure its long-term viability. President Trump’s promise to eliminate the taxation of Social Security benefits, while popular with many retirees, would exacerbate the program’s financial problems and accelerate its depletion.

Rather than sticking to this politically appealing but fiscally irresponsible promise, it may be necessary for Trump to break it in order to preserve the future of Social Security. While breaking this promise would be a difficult decision, it could ultimately be the best choice for ensuring that Social Security remains a reliable source of income for future generations of Americans.

Disclaimer – Our editorial team has thoroughly fact-checked this article to ensure its accuracy and eliminate any potential misinformation. We are dedicated to upholding the highest standards of integrity in our content.

About The Author