Statewide Efforts Launched to Mitigate Public Defender Shortfall in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania is facing a significant shortage of public defenders, with over 60 counties lacking sufficient legal representation for low-income residents. To address this issue, the University of Pittsburgh School of Law and the Public Defender Association of Pennsylvania are co-hosting a statewide Career Day in Pittsburgh. This event aims to connect law students from various institutions with potential job opportunities in public defenders’ offices across the state.

Megan Lovett, the Director of Public Interest and Pro Bono Initiatives at the University of Pittsburgh, has reported receiving over 50 applications for both internships and attorney positions. She highlighted that last year’s fair successfully placed students in counties they might not have previously considered, benefiting areas struggling to recruit from the law student population. Lovett expressed hope that this year’s event will similarly attract applicants statewide.

Annually, public defenders’ offices in Pennsylvania manage caseloads that would typically require more than 1,200 full-time attorneys. However, only about 850 attorneys are currently employed statewide, leading to a substantial shortfall in legal representation.

Andrew Capone, Assistant Director of Training for the Public Defender Association of Pennsylvania, emphasized that a lack of state funding has historically limited public defenders’ offices, contributing to the current shortage. He noted that until last year, Pennsylvania was one of only two states that did not fund public defender offices, leaving the responsibility to individual counties. Governor Josh Shapiro has since allocated $7.5 million in the state budget as an initial investment in statewide indigent defense.

Despite this historic allocation, when divided among 67 counties, the funding’s impact is minimal, potentially supporting only one additional attorney or staff member per office. This highlights the need for continued efforts to recruit and retain qualified public defenders to ensure adequate legal representation for low-income residents.

The shortage of public defenders in Pennsylvania has significant implications for the criminal justice system. Without sufficient legal representation, low-income individuals may face challenges in receiving fair trials, potentially leading to wrongful convictions or unjust sentencing. The state’s recent steps toward funding indigent defense mark progress, but experts argue that more substantial investments are necessary to address decades of neglect.

A report by the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School’s Quattrone Center for the Fair Administration of Justice analyzed nearly one million criminal court dockets from 2016 to 2022. The study found that only six of the state’s 66 counties with public defenders have enough attorneys to meet caseload demands. Statewide, there is a 30% shortfall in the number of public defenders, underscoring the need for increased staffing and resources.

In response to these challenges, the Shapiro-Davis Administration has approved applications for historic indigent defense grant funding. The 2024-25 state budget proposes a $2.5 million increase for indigent defense funding, totaling $10 million to be distributed through the Pennsylvania Commission on Crime and Delinquency (PCCD). This funding aims to improve the capacity and effectiveness of indigent defense services by supporting staff recruitment and retention, enhancing data collection, and providing necessary training and professional development.

Lieutenant Governor Austin Davis, Chair of the PCCD, emphasized the importance of this funding in building equity within the criminal justice system. He stated that while more work is needed, sustained and dedicated funding for public defenders is a critical starting point. The administration is working with county partners to ensure these resources are utilized effectively across the Commonwealth.

Despite these efforts, challenges remain. The American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania has filed a lawsuit against the state, alleging that the current funding levels are insufficient to meet constitutional obligations. The lawsuit argues that Pennsylvania’s reliance on county funding for public defenders leads to significant disparities and deficiencies in available resources, potentially violating the rights of indigent defendants.

The recruitment event in Pittsburgh represents a proactive step toward addressing the public defender shortage. By connecting law students with potential employment opportunities, the event aims to bolster the workforce dedicated to providing legal representation for low-income residents. However, systemic issues such as funding disparities and high caseloads continue to pose challenges. Ongoing advocacy and policy reforms are essential to ensure that all Pennsylvanians receive the legal representation guaranteed by the Constitution.

In conclusion, while recent initiatives and funding allocations mark progress in addressing Pennsylvania’s public defender shortage, significant work remains. Comprehensive solutions involving increased funding, policy reforms, and effective recruitment strategies are necessary to ensure equitable access to justice for all residents.


Pennsylvania is facing a significant shortage of public defenders, with over 60 counties lacking sufficient legal representation for low-income residents. To address this issue, the University of Pittsburgh School of Law and the Public Defender Association of Pennsylvania are co-hosting a statewide Career Day in Pittsburgh. This event aims to connect law students from various institutions with potential job opportunities in public defenders’ offices across the state.

Megan Lovett, the Director of Public Interest and Pro Bono Initiatives at the University of Pittsburgh, has reported receiving over 50 applications for both internships and attorney positions. She highlighted that last year’s fair successfully placed students in counties they might not have previously considered, benefiting areas struggling to recruit from the law student population. Lovett expressed hope that this year’s event will similarly attract applicants statewide.

Annually, public defenders’ offices in Pennsylvania manage caseloads that would typically require more than 1,200 full-time attorneys. However, only about 850 attorneys are currently employed statewide, leading to a substantial shortfall in legal representation.

Andrew Capone, Assistant Director of Training for the Public Defender Association of Pennsylvania, emphasized that a lack of state funding has historically limited public defenders’ offices, contributing to the current shortage. He noted that until last year, Pennsylvania was one of only two states that did not fund public defender offices, leaving the responsibility to individual counties. Governor Josh Shapiro has since allocated $7.5 million in the state budget as an initial investment in statewide indigent defense.

Despite this historic allocation, when divided among 67 counties, the funding’s impact is minimal, potentially supporting only one additional attorney or staff member per office. This highlights the need for continued efforts to recruit and retain qualified public defenders to ensure adequate legal representation for low-income residents.

The shortage of public defenders in Pennsylvania has significant implications for the criminal justice system. Without sufficient legal representation, low-income individuals may face challenges in receiving fair trials, potentially leading to wrongful convictions or unjust sentencing. The state’s recent steps toward funding indigent defense mark progress, but experts argue that more substantial investments are necessary to address decades of neglect.

A report by the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School’s Quattrone Center for the Fair Administration of Justice analyzed nearly one million criminal court dockets from 2016 to 2022. The study found that only six of the state’s 66 counties with public defenders have enough attorneys to meet caseload demands. Statewide, there is a 30% shortfall in the number of public defenders, underscoring the need for increased staffing and resources.

In response to these challenges, the Shapiro-Davis Administration has approved applications for historic indigent defense grant funding. The 2024-25 state budget proposes a $2.5 million increase for indigent defense funding, totaling $10 million to be distributed through the Pennsylvania Commission on Crime and Delinquency (PCCD). This funding aims to improve the capacity and effectiveness of indigent defense services by supporting staff recruitment and retention, enhancing data collection, and providing necessary training and professional development.

Lieutenant Governor Austin Davis, Chair of the PCCD, emphasized the importance of this funding in building equity within the criminal justice system. He stated that while more work is needed, sustained and dedicated funding for public defenders is a critical starting point. The administration is working with county partners to ensure these resources are utilized effectively across the Commonwealth.

Despite these efforts, challenges remain. The American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania has filed a lawsuit against the state, alleging that the current funding levels are insufficient to meet constitutional obligations. The lawsuit argues that Pennsylvania’s reliance on county funding for public defenders leads to significant disparities and deficiencies in available resources, potentially violating the rights of indigent defendants.

The recruitment event in Pittsburgh represents a proactive step toward addressing the public defender shortage. By connecting law students with potential employment opportunities, the event aims to bolster the workforce dedicated to providing legal representation for low-income residents. However, systemic issues such as funding disparities and high caseloads continue to pose challenges. Ongoing advocacy and policy reforms are essential to ensure that all Pennsylvanians receive the legal representation guaranteed by the Constitution.

Disclaimer – Our editorial team has thoroughly fact-checked this article to ensure its accuracy and eliminate any potential misinformation. We are dedicated to upholding the highest standards of integrity in our content.

About The Author