The future of the Illinois state flag is in limbo as the Illinois Flag Commission nears the end of a design contest, which will ultimately influence whether the state’s flag will be redesigned. A new design contest was launched after the state received almost 5,000 submissions, from which 10 finalists were selected. The public can vote until February 14, and each resident is allowed one vote per day. The contest is advisory, meaning the Illinois legislature will ultimately make the decision whether to adopt a new design or retain the existing flag.
The current Illinois flag, which has been used for over 50 years, remains controversial. Its design features a bald eagle on a white background with the state motto and the year Illinois was established. Despite some criticisms of the flag, there are many who appreciate its symbolism and believe it should remain the state’s official banner.
Opposition to the Design Contest
While the contest has sparked public engagement, not everyone is convinced that redesigning the flag is necessary. Illinois State Senator Doris Turner, a Democrat from Springfield who sponsored the bill leading to the design competition, views the process as an opportunity to engage the public and foster state pride. Some, however, believe it’s a waste of resources, especially given the state’s economic challenges.
A local resident, Ayn Patton Bartok, voiced her opposition, arguing that the state should focus on more pressing matters than redesigning the flag. “I’m concerned that our state is not necessarily physically sound, and this seems to be a frivolous endeavor,” she said, questioning whether a new flag would improve the state’s business relations or attract new residents.
The Case for the Current Flag
State Senator Terri Bryant, a Republican from Murphysboro, is a strong advocate for the current flag. She, along with several of her neighbors, flies the Illinois flag at their homes. Bryant has argued that the flag has meaningful elements that should be preserved, including the eagle and the sun, which appear to move as the flag waves. These features are seen as symbols of vitality and strength that represent the state’s identity.
While Bryant acknowledges the potential benefits of a new flag, she maintains that the current design resonates with many residents and reflects Illinois’ history and spirit. “There are things about our flag that stand out,” she said, emphasizing how the flag moves in a way that symbolizes water and sunlight, two natural resources closely tied to the state.
The Criticism of the Flag’s Design
Vexillologist Ted Kaye, an expert in flag design, has criticized the current Illinois state flag as a “seal on a bedsheet.” This term is a dismissive reference to flag design in vexillology circles, which generally reject the use of seals on flags. Kaye argues that a flag should represent the people, not the government, and that the current flag is difficult to distinguish from a distance due to its detailed elements, such as the eagle and state motto.
Despite these criticisms, many Illinoisans, including John Kokoris, a local historian, have expressed their fondness for the current flag. Kokoris, known as “Mr. Illinois,” has noted that many people in the state continue to express pride in the flag, appreciating the historical significance of the eagle and the state motto.
The Impact of the Flag Contest on Civic Engagement
Regardless of whether the current flag remains or a new design is adopted, the flag contest has had a positive impact on civic engagement in Illinois. According to Senator Turner, the contest has sparked conversations and encouraged public involvement in a process that many may not have previously considered. The commission, which includes both Democrats and Republicans, emphasized that the contest was designed to encourage participation from all residents, including younger generations.
In fact, a significant number of submissions came from elementary, middle, and high school students, which Turner sees as a sign of the contest’s success in increasing civic awareness.
The Costs of Changing the Flag
Changing the flag would undoubtedly involve costs, both for state agencies and local governments. States like Utah and Minnesota, which have recently redesigned their flags, have reported significant expenses related to the change. For instance, Utah spent nearly $500,000 on its flag redesign and awarded $5,000 in prizes for finalists. In Minnesota, the cost of replacing old state flags was high for local governments, with some reporting costs upwards of $50,000 for updating uniforms and signage.
Despite these potential costs, Senator Turner is confident that the transition will be manageable and gradual. She emphasized that the state would follow the model used in Utah, phasing out old flags gradually rather than making an abrupt change.
Designing the New Flag: Challenges and Criticisms
The process for selecting finalists has not been without controversy. Some, like Kokoris, have argued that the 10 finalists chosen do not reflect the full spectrum of creative possibilities. Kokoris believes the finalists were too similar, with many featuring elements like stars, stripes, and Lincoln’s head, which he finds uninspiring.
Ted Kaye, the vexillologist, also criticized the process, arguing that the inclusion of the current flag as one of the finalists could skew the vote. Since voters could select the existing flag alongside new designs, it is possible that the current flag could win by default, even though a majority of voters may prefer a new design.
A State Divided on Its Identity
Illinois, like many states, finds itself at a crossroads regarding its flag. While the contest has raised awareness about the flag and provided an opportunity for residents to express their opinions, it has also revealed the deep divisions within the state regarding its identity and representation. Some see the current flag as a meaningful symbol of the state’s history, while others feel it is outdated and does not reflect modern Illinois.
The debate over the state flag is emblematic of broader conversations about state identity, civic pride, and the role of symbols in shaping public life. Whether or not Illinois adopts a new flag, the process has created a platform for Illinoisans to reflect on their state’s heritage and what it means to be part of the Land of Lincoln.
Conclusion
The Illinois state flag contest, which concludes its voting process on February 14, 2025, has become a reflection of the state’s ongoing debate about its identity. While there are strong proponents for keeping the current flag, many see it as an opportunity for a fresh start, a chance to redesign a flag that better represents the state’s people, values, and history.
As the commission prepares to send its final report to state lawmakers by April 1, Illinoisans will be waiting to see whether the flag will change or remain the same. Whatever the outcome, the flag debate has already succeeded in one important goal: it has fostered greater civic engagement and pride, even if it remains uncertain which design will ultimately fly over the state.
Disclaimer – Our editorial team has thoroughly fact-checked this article to ensure its accuracy and eliminate any potential misinformation. We are dedicated to upholding the highest standards of integrity in our content.
About The Author
More Stories
Illinois State Flag Faces Uncertainty Amid Design Contest
Illinois State Flag Faces Uncertainty Amid Design Contest
Illinois State Flag Faces Uncertainty Amid Design Contest