Maine’s Deadly Force Review Panel Highlights Mental Illness and Substance Abuse in Police Shootings

In Maine, incidents involving deadly police force are a somber reminder of the challenges law enforcement faces while responding to situations that may involve mental illness, substance abuse, and alcohol. The latest annual report from the Maine Deadly Force Review Panel, released in January 2025, examines the causes and dynamics behind eight police shootings that took place in 2024. These incidents resulted in either fatalities or severe injuries. The panel’s investigation reveals striking patterns in the nature of these encounters, particularly concerning the role mental health issues, alcohol, and drugs played in escalating these dangerous interactions. The report also offers a set of recommendations aimed at improving police responses and minimizing the risks involved in such encounters.

Mental Illness, Alcohol, and Drugs as Common Themes: One of the most consistent findings of the 2024 report is the recurring presence of mental illness, alcohol, and drugs in police-involved shootings. These factors were present in the majority of the cases reviewed by the panel. Mental health issues have long been a challenge for law enforcement officers, who are often the first responders to incidents involving individuals in psychological distress. In many of these situations, the lack of a trained mental health professional on the scene leads to confrontations that quickly escalate.

Alcohol and drug use also contributed to the volatile nature of many of these encounters. Officers often face individuals under the influence, who may be more prone to aggressive behavior, making it more difficult for law enforcement to assess the situation and de-escalate. In such high-stakes scenarios, the presence of substances compounds the danger to both the officers and the public.

The review panel emphasized that these themes are not isolated but rather indicative of broader trends in police interactions with individuals facing mental health crises or substance-related issues. According to the panel, a disproportionate number of police shootings can be traced back to situations involving people who were either intoxicated, under the influence of drugs, or experiencing acute psychological distress.

Panel’s Recommendations: In response to these findings, the Maine Deadly Force Review Panel issued several recommendations aimed at improving police training, operational protocols, and response strategies for such incidents. These recommendations seek to address the challenges posed by mental illness, alcohol, and drug use, while ensuring better safety measures for both law enforcement and civilians. Some of the panel’s key recommendations include:

1. Evacuation of Nearby Buildings: The panel recommends that, whenever possible, nearby buildings should be evacuated when an incident involving deadly force occurs. This is especially important in residential areas or places with a high concentration of people. Evacuating the surrounding area can reduce the risk of additional harm and protect innocent bystanders from getting caught in the crossfire.
2. Activation of Body Cameras: The review panel emphasized the importance of body camera usage in maintaining transparency during high-stress encounters. One of the recommendations is that officers should turn on their body cameras as soon as they are dispatched to a scene. This would ensure that there is a clear, unbiased record of the events leading up to and following a deadly force incident. Having this footage available will not only assist in investigations but also increase public trust in law enforcement’s actions.
3. Additional Training on Electronic Weapons: Another key recommendation is that officers receive more comprehensive training on the use of less-than-lethal weapons, such as Tasers. This can provide officers with more options when attempting to subdue a suspect without resorting to lethal force. The panel also stressed the need to reduce the potential for “weapons confusion,” which occurs when an officer mistakenly uses a firearm instead of a less-lethal weapon, such as a Taser.
4. Command Structure and Tactical Team Involvement: The panel also discussed the importance of clear leadership in high-stakes situations. Unless a tactical team is present, the ranking officer from the jurisdiction where the incident occurs should assume command and control unless the responsibility is transferred. This ensures that there is a decisive and effective response to the situation, preventing confusion and disorganization among responding officers.
5. Use of Police Vehicles for Cover: The review panel also recommended more consideration for using police vehicles as cover during dangerous situations. Police vehicles can provide a protective barrier for officers and other first responders, helping to shield them from gunfire or other forms of danger. The panel encouraged law enforcement agencies to better utilize their vehicles in situations where cover is needed to protect lives.
6. Requesting Backup in Domestic Violence Calls: Another significant recommendation from the panel was for officers to request backup during domestic violence calls, particularly when there is no imminent danger. Domestic violence situations can quickly escalate, and having additional officers on the scene can help prevent physical confrontations and provide a greater sense of security for both officers and the individuals involved. A multi-officer presence often discourages violent behavior, which can be crucial when responding to potentially dangerous domestic disputes.
7. Collaboration with Crisis Centers: The panel also encouraged law enforcement agencies to work with local facilities, such as Bread of Life, to develop a more comprehensive and effective response plan for incidents involving mental illness and substance abuse. By training officers to handle these types of situations with more understanding and compassion, the panel believes that the number of deadly force incidents can be reduced. Collaborative efforts between law enforcement and mental health professionals can help prevent situations where police are forced to use deadly force.

Conclusion: The findings from the 2024 report by the Maine Deadly Force Review Panel shed light on the often overlooked factors that contribute to police shootings. Mental illness, alcohol, and drugs are common themes in many of these incidents, highlighting the need for better training, increased awareness, and more comprehensive response strategies. The panel’s recommendations reflect a broader push to reform law enforcement practices to prioritize safety, de-escalation, and effective crisis management. By addressing the root causes of these shootings and providing officers with the tools and knowledge to handle high-risk situations, Maine can work toward minimizing deadly force incidents and fostering safer communities for all.

Disclaimer – Our editorial team has thoroughly fact-checked this article to ensure its accuracy and eliminate any potential misinformation. We are dedicated to upholding the highest standards of integrity in our content.

About The Author