Rare Lincoln Wheat Penny Worth $54K Could Still Be in Circulation

Although there are several examples of Old Lincoln Wheat Pennies, the 1925-S Wheat Penny stands out as a unique and valuable coin. This very small copper coin, which was struck during a period in which the United States Mint was reducing the output of pennies, has become a significant reward for collectors, particularly when it is in mint condition.

It is a different story to discover one that is in excellent condition, despite the fact that more than 26 million were produced. At auction, a stunning sample that was graded MS65 Red could be purchased for an astounding $54,625 dollars. I’m going to explain why this penny is so precious, as well as how you can tell if you’ve got a winner on your hands.

Importance

When a penny from 1925 bears the “S” mint mark, it indicates that it was produced by the San Francisco Mint. In 1925, the manufacture of pennies was being slowed down at all three of the United States mints. Before a few years had passed, they were producing at least 200 million pennies annually through their production process.

Consequently, despite the fact that 26 million could appear to be a large number, it was thought to be a smaller mintage back then. Due to the limited number of coins produced, coins such as the 1925-S became more desirable to collectors throughout the course of time.

Rarity

There is not a great deal of difficulty in locating 1925-S pennies that are in fact worn and circulated. However, if you are looking for one that is in perfect Mint State (MS63 or better), you are going to have a very difficult time going about your search.

Finding a cent that is a Mint State Red (RD) example, which indicates that the penny has maintained its original vivid copper hue, is the real prize. Exemplars of high-grade red are highly uncommon and thus extremely precious.

An MS65 Red 1925-S penny was purchased at Heritage Auctions in 2005 for the price of $54,625 dollars. If you were to hold onto a single penny and discover that it is worth more than a luxury automobile, what would you do?

Here’s a quick snapshot:

Grade	Rarity	Estimated Value
Circulated (XF-AU)	Common	$20–$150
Mint State (MS63)	Scarce	$500+
Mint State (MS65 RD)	Rare	$20,000–$55,000

Identification

Think you might have a 1925-S Wheat Penny? Here’s what to look for:

• Date: 1925 stamped on the obverse (front)
• Mint Mark: Small “S” below the date
• Reverse Design: Traditional wheat stalks on the back (used from 1909 to 1958)

If your penny still shines with its original reddish glow and shows little to no wear, you could be holding a serious collector’s item.

Value

When it comes to the value of the 1925-S penny, condition is truly the most important factor. It is possible that a badly worn one will only fetch a few dollars. On the other hand, the most value may be found in a coin that has distinct details and its original color.

In order to finish out their collections, collectors are continually looking for specimens of the highest possible quality. In the event that you have reason to believe that you own a valuable coin, it is imperative that you have it graded by a competent agency such as PCGS or NGC.

In the world of coins, the 1925-S Wheat Penny is an excellent illustration of why quality is often more important than quantity. In spite of the fact that millions were produced, there are just a few that are still in excellent form today.

If you come across one that has a mint mark that looks like a “S” and it appears to be very fresh, you shouldn’t throw it away in your change jar. It is possible that you are sitting on a modest fortune.

About The Author