Crystal Rogers Case: Steve Lawson’s Attorneys Cite Evidence Overload in Trial Motion

Steve Lawson, one of the individuals charged in connection with the disappearance of Bardstown mother Crystal Rogers, has formally requested a delay in his upcoming trial. His legal team filed a motion in Nelson Circuit Court on January 5, seeking to postpone the trial, which is currently scheduled to begin on February 11, 2025. The defense argues that they need more time to thoroughly review the extensive evidence provided by the prosecution to prepare an adequate defense.

This request marks the latest development in the high-profile case surrounding the disappearance of Crystal Rogers, which has captured national attention for nearly a decade. Rogers, a 35-year-old mother of five, vanished under mysterious circumstances in July 2015. Despite years of investigations, her body has never been found, though authorities presume she is deceased. The case saw significant progress in 2023 when Lawson, his son Joseph Lawson, and Rogers’ then-boyfriend Brooks Houck were arrested and charged in connection with her disappearance.

A Change in Legal Representation

Steve Lawson’s defense team cites multiple reasons for requesting the trial delay, including the need to review what they describe as an overwhelming amount of evidence. In August 2024, Lawson dismissed his previous attorney, Theodore Lavit, and hired a new legal team, consisting of attorneys Darren Wolff and Zach Buckler. Since taking on the case, Wolff and Buckler have met with Lawson multiple times to discuss the charges and the evidence against him. However, they argue that the time since their appointment has been insufficient to adequately prepare for trial.

In their motion, Lawson’s attorneys described the volume of evidence as “anomalously high,” noting that much of it had been compiled over years by federal investigators. They also revealed that some of this material was handed over only recently, adding to the challenge of preparing a comprehensive defense. While prosecutors claim that much of the evidence is either “duplicative” or “irrelevant,” Lawson’s legal team insists that a full review of all materials is essential to ensure fairness.

Concerns About Evidence and Trial Readiness

The defense’s motion outlines several concerns about the current trial schedule. One key issue is that Lawson himself has not yet had sufficient time to review the evidence in detail. In an affidavit accompanying the motion, Lawson expressed his own need for more time to understand the discovery materials. “It is impossible to mount an adequate defense without sufficient time to understand and evaluate the evidence against me,” Lawson stated.

Charges and Legal Proceedings

Steve Lawson faces charges of tampering with physical evidence and conspiracy to commit murder. His trial is the first of two connected to the Crystal Rogers case that are scheduled for 2025. Lawson’s son, Joseph Lawson, faces similar charges, while Brooks Houck, Rogers’ then-boyfriend, is charged with murder and tampering with physical evidence. All three men have pleaded not guilty.

The legal proceedings for the co-defendants have been complex. In November 2024, Judge Charles Simms III ruled that Houck and Joseph Lawson would be tried separately from Steve Lawson. Houck’s trial is scheduled to begin on June 24, 2025. Given the high-profile nature of the case and the media attention it has garnered, the trials will take place in Warren County rather than Nelson County, where the charges were filed.

The Disappearance of Crystal Rogers

Crystal Rogers was last seen alive on July 3, 2015. Her disappearance sent shockwaves through the small town of Bardstown, Kentucky, which had already been grappling with other unsolved crimes. Rogers’ car was discovered abandoned along the Bluegrass Parkway with her phone, keys, and purse still inside, leading investigators to suspect foul play.

The case remained unsolved for years until significant developments occurred in 2023. That year, authorities arrested Brooks Houck, Steve Lawson, and Joseph Lawson in connection with Rogers’ disappearance. Investigators allege that Houck, who was dating Rogers at the time of her disappearance, was involved in her murder, while the Lawsons are accused of assisting in covering up the crime.

Implications of a Trial Delay

If granted, the trial delay could push back the timeline for resolving a case that has already spanned nearly a decade. For Rogers’ family, the postponement would represent yet another painful delay in their quest for justice. Over the years, her family has remained vocal about their determination to find answers and hold those responsible accountable.

However, legal experts note that granting the delay may be necessary to ensure that Lawson receives a fair trialThe court is expected to rule on the motion in the coming days. If the delay is approved, it could set a new timeline for the trial and potentially impact the scheduling of the related trials for Joseph Lawson and Brooks Houck.

Community Impact and Public Interest

The disappearance of Crystal Rogers has left a lasting impact on the Bardstown community, which has been at the center of multiple high-profile criminal cases in recent years. The unresolved nature of Rogers’ case has fueled speculation and anxiety among residents, as well as intense media scrutiny. True crime enthusiasts have also followed the case closely, with many sharing theories and discussing developments online.

The trials of Steve Lawson, Joseph Lawson, and Brooks Houck are expected to shed new light on the circumstances surrounding Rogers’ disappearance. For the Bardstown community and the Rogers family, the hope is that the legal proceedings will finally bring clarity and justice to a case that has haunted them for nearly a decade.

What’s Next?

As the court considers Steve Lawson’s request for a trial postponement, all eyes remain on Bardstown and the unfolding legal proceedings. The decision will determine whether Lawson’s trial proceeds as scheduled in February or is delayed to allow his defense team more time to prepare.

The upcoming trials will likely reveal new details about one of Kentucky’s most infamous unsolved cases. For Crystal Rogers’ family, the trials represent a long-awaited opportunity to seek justice for their loved one. Whether that justice is achieved will depend on the evidence presented and the integrity of the judicial process.

Disclaimer – Our editorial team has thoroughly fact-checked this article to ensure its accuracy and eliminate any potential misinformation. We are dedicated to upholding the highest standards of integrity in our content.

About The Author